First there was Harbor Pilot Antonio Martinez Carvajal dating back to 1565. He was followed by Cristobal Carvajal of “The Company of Colonel Hernando de Uruna” in 1566. Next followed Pedro de Carvajal whose name appears on the St. Augustine Garrison List in 1578. These three men have been identified as of Jewish descent by Professor Roger L. Martinez-Dávila, Associate Professor of History & Director of Graduate Studies at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. Martinez has traced the family ties and intermarriages of the Jewish rabbinic ha-Levi lineage of Burgos, Spain (which became the converso Santa María clan) with the Old Christian Carvajal line of Plasencia, Spain, Martínez-Dávila and demonstrated the family’s changing identity. The positive identification was made as part of a project undertaken by the St. Augustine Jewish Historical Society.
Now Dr. Stanley Hordes, formerly the State Historian of New Mexico and the co-director of a research project on the secret Jews, or “Crypto-Jews,” at the University of New Mexico’s Latin American Institute, has identified Pedro Luis de Paez, who brought his family to St. Augustine in 1583, as descended from Jews. Hordes discovered in Archivo General de Indias documents pertaining to de Paez, whose name appears on colonial musters in the notes of Dr. Eugene Lyon, historian of Colonial St. Augustine and have been put to use by the St. Augustine Jewish Historical Society.
To obtain permission to come to Florida, de Paez sought and received a waiver of the Limpieza de Sangre, Purity of Blood, law, a hallmark of descendants of Jews who were not permitted in Florida at the time. A 1583 document referred to Paez, as returning to the province of Florida, along with his wife, children, and servants. The normal requirement to show proof of one’s Limpieza de Sangre was waived in this case. Permission was finally granted in 1585, the same year that another document showed him as having brought 30 African slaves to Florida. At the time, Pedro Luis de Paez was in Barga, Portugal where conversos dominated the trade in African slaves.
Documents related to de Paez and his role in St. Augustine have been located in University of Florida Digital Collections part of the George A. Smathers Library and the “Unearthing St. Augustine’s Colonial Heritage” collection. The St. Augustine Jewish Historical Society continues the quest to identify the South’s earliest Jews.
Dr. Stanley Hordes Professor Roger L. Martinez-Davila